Saturday, February 12, 2011

“Anthropologists have favored studying non-western cultures as a way of fulfilling their mission to study the diverse ways of mankind; they have not had an intense commitment to social reform because of their relativistic stance and a belief that such a stance was necessary to a truly “objective, detatched, scientific perspective,” or because they thought that other such a sociologists were involved in social reform”

Do you believe that being objective means that you can not participate in fighting for, creating, or implementing social reform? How does this relate to and differ from the argument Stacey makes about feminist ethnographies?

2 comments:

  1. Objectivity has its place, and it does have some advantages. An objective presentation may be more persuasive and effective in working for social justice. Objectivity may also advance the cause of understanding from all parties involved.

    However, I do not hold the opinion that we can be entirely objective, though we can the attempt some objectivity as part of the scientific method.

    As for the lack of "commitment to social reform", well, any science that places science or objectivity above the welfare of human life is useless. We all have a responsibility to call out injustices in whatever way and with whatever tools we have available to us.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The question is rather hard to answer for me partly dbecause it brings objectivity back into question. I think that objectivity as a concept is one that is changing (and for the better, I would argue). Objectivity from a positivists perspective would not allow for social reform, because it would likely leave room for a certain bias (in advocacy, or in critique of the subject). But I do think that how we think about objectivity can be reinvented in a manner that would create space for social change. Naturally, some of Haraways arguments come to mind. So on one hand I don't believe that with our current (primitive) idea of objectivity would allow for this "fighting" for social change, but that these new ideas of objectivity must take social reform into heavy consideration.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.