RIC - Ethnographic Research Methods
This blog is for discussing course topics and concerns in Research Methods in Cultural Anthropology, ANTH 433. Discussion leaders should post their comments and questions, and others should respond here.
Sunday, February 20, 2011
Speed
On page 9, Shannon Speed mentions "there was no 'neutral observer' stance available" to her in her research. If it holds that you cannot have an objective position in some anthropological research, and the basis of science is objective observation, does this then negate the idea of anthropology being a science? Is it a science in some cases, and not in others? Or since Speed refers to her work as "activist research" would her work even fall into the category of anthropology?
SPEED
The article recounts Speed's experience with being an activist while doing her research. Because of the nature of Chiapas, the situation was highly politicized. Speed took the position as an activist both for her own practical and ethical reasons, but also because she thought this was a better approach for anthropology in general. Do you all think that taking such a 'situated' stance is plausible for other ethnographic projects? (consider your own) What are some of the benefits and dangers involved in this approach?
Friday, February 18, 2011
Thorne: You Still Takin' Notes?
Thorne discusses the ethics regarding the rights of subjects "to be treated as persons rather than objects" (Thorne: 1980, 285). In his article, this is in reference to individuals. How would that change if we choose to study up? Do we owe corporations and government entities the same rights as we owe individuals? Are they subject to the same potential for harm?
Wednesday, February 16, 2011
Marcus Article:
What do you think are some of the advantages and disadvantages of multi-sited ethnography?He poses the question whether or not is multi-sited field work is practical, what do you think?
Saturday, February 12, 2011
Nader encourages creativity in ethnographic research as a means of remaining excited about a project and as a necessity in cases where traditional fieldwork is impractical. What are some creative ways to do ethnographic research? Furthermore, what are some creative possibilities in presenting the findings of research? How can we make this work exciting to the general public? Or would you want to disregard traditional styles of research presentation for the sake of a larger potential audience?
“Anthropologists have favored studying non-western cultures as a way of fulfilling their mission to study the diverse ways of mankind; they have not had an intense commitment to social reform because of their relativistic stance and a belief that such a stance was necessary to a truly “objective, detatched, scientific perspective,” or because they thought that other such a sociologists were involved in social reform”
Do you believe that being objective means that you can not participate in fighting for, creating, or implementing social reform? How does this relate to and differ from the argument Stacey makes about feminist ethnographies?
Do you believe that being objective means that you can not participate in fighting for, creating, or implementing social reform? How does this relate to and differ from the argument Stacey makes about feminist ethnographies?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)